Legal Action Launched Against Ontario’s Omnibus Bill 197

Details: Created on Monday, 31 August 2020 09:57

Defending the health and prosperity of communities and the environment

Toronto, August 31, 2020 — In the wake of the passage of Ontario's controversial Bill 197, a legal challenge against the legislation has been commenced by Earthroots; Canadian Environmental Law Association; Ontario Nature; Cooper Price, a 16-year old activist; and Michel Koostachin, who was born and raised in Attawapiskat.

These parties have jointly filed an application for judicial review that asks the Divisional Court to issue declaratory relief and other remedies in relation to the omnibus legislation, which overhauls the Environmental Assessment Act and amends other provincial laws.

“Bill 197 holds true to an insidious pattern of environmental deregulation that reflects neither the values nor the long-term interests of Ontarians who understand the importance of a healthy environment,” says Caroline Schultz, Ontario Nature’s Executive Director.

The application alleges that Bill 197 was enacted in a manner that failed to comply with the public notice/ comment requirements of Ontario's Environmental Bill of Rights (EBR). Moreover, it is inconsistent with international law conventions, principles and norms on environmental assessment, public participation, and human rights applicable in Ontario.

Gord Miller, Chair of Earthroots says, "As Environmental Commissioner of Ontario for 15 years, I constantly had to work to protect and maintain the EBR rights of the people to participate in government decision making about our environmental heritage. Bill 197 has gutted those rights and set public policy back decades. We must react. We must defend those rights for the sake of future generations."

Represented by Joseph Castrilli, Richard Lindgren and David Estrin of CELA, the applicants are seeking a declaration by the Court that the Government of Ontario violated provincial and international law in enacting Bill 197, and an order from the Court directing the Government of Ontario to conduct meaningful public consultation on the environmentally significant aspects of Bill 197 before they are proclaimed into force.

“The government is removing space for youth input on our own futures,” says youth climate activist Cooper Price. “This lawsuit is a fight to uplift the youth voice and a fight for the environment.”

Says Michel Koostachin, “Our Natural Laws are greater than man made laws, we live in harmony with the animals and have respect for our Mother Earth.”

"It is critically important that we have robust environmental assessment and planning laws that allow for strong public participation, and that protect health and the environment for generations to come, especially for those who don't have a 'seat at the table' where many decisions are made," stated Theresa McClenaghan, Executive Director and Counsel with the Canadian Environmental Law Association.

Be part of the generosity movement on #GivingTuesdayNow

Details: Created on Tuesday, 05 May 2020 12:41

On #GivingTuesdayNow we want to express our gratitude to every worker putting themselves at risk to keep us healthy and safe, and to every person doing their part by adhering to social distancing practices to help flatten the curve. We have come a long way!

Despite our physical separation, we see people who are newly empowered to be a part of the growing generosity movement — checking in with loved ones, friends or neighbours in need, volunteering for a community initiative, or supporting a favourite charity.

Charities like Earthroots exist because groups of passionate people just like you self-organize around ideas that can make the world a better place.

The pandemic has brought many inequities and weak spots in our society to the forefront — yet we have also seen the almost unbelievable impact our individual choices can make collectively when we act with a common goal. Witnessing these changes in real time crystallizes our hope for a future where the interconnected well-being of humans, animals and plants — our living, breathing, fragile life systems — are not just sustained by our goals and actions, but flourish.

If you believe we can shape a better future together, please support Earthroots' steadfast work by clicking on the Donate Now button to the left.

Stay Empowered ~ Be Generous ~ Stay Safe

The Ford government has created a Black Hole of Environmental Public Accountability, hidden behind the COVID-19 response

Details: Created on Tuesday, 21 April 2020 19:05

Don't let your environmental concerns be silenced - take action now!

A special blog by Gord Miller, Earthroots Chair and former Environmental Commissioner of Ontario

Citing administrative challenges created by the COVID-19 response, the Ford government has announced a new regulation which removes the requirement for numerous government ministries to notify and consult the public before they pass environmentally significant laws, regulations or policies, or before they issue certain environmentally important licenses or permits. Formerly these decisions had to be posted on the Environmental Bill of Rights Registry for at least 30 days before they could be implemented. These Registry postings gave Earthroots the ability to find out what the government was up to and give us a way to mobilize our thousands of supporters to raise concerns and objections, and otherwise let the ministry involved know what they thought of the proposal through the Registry comment process. Earthroots campaigns based on Registry postings have resulted in a number of proposed environmentally damaging ideas being withdrawn, reversed or modified.

This new regulation will suspend the use of the Registry for the duration of the COVID-19 emergency (however long that is) and continue for 30 days after it ends. Not only will that blind Earthroots and the public to controversial decisions being considered and put in place during that period, but we won’t know afterwards what was actually added, cancelled or changed. If this emergency goes on for many months as some have suggested, there will be a permanent “Black Hole” in the public policy record. We might not find out that an old-growth forestry policy had been changed, or a controversial water taking permit had been issued, until perhaps a year or more later when some damage or problem comes to light. and the ministry responsible simply says that they made the pertinent decision during the blackout.

A special message from our Chair, Gord Miller

Details: Created on Wednesday, 08 April 2020 19:41

While the Earthroots office is currently closed, our dedicated team continues to advocate for Ontario's threatened wilderness, wildlife and watersheds, from home. We want to keep in touch with you during these unprecedented times. Contact us via email at This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it., or you can send a message directly to our Executive Director, Amber Ellis, at This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it.

Stay connected through our e-news or social media platforms.

Twitter: twitter.com/Earthroots
Facebook: facebook.com/Earthroots.Coalition
Subscribe to our e-news at earthroots.org/wd-signup

Many of you have regularly contributed to our campaigns through our year-round door canvass, a grassroots outreach and fundraising program we launched way back in 1992. With the closure of the canvass in mid-March, we will be missing the face-to-face interactions with you in the coming months. We are encouraging our dedicated supporters to donate online while we continue to protect our communities through social distancing. If you are able to contribute any amount - large or small - it will make a big difference to our steadfast work! Just click on the Donate Now button at the top of the page.

The road for environmental advocacy is not easy and with the ongoing rollbacks under the Ford government, we know we are in a marathon. But because of your alliance, we never stop marching forward. And together, we have the power to build a sustainable future.

Thank you for always rooting for us!

Temagami watchdogs sue Ford government over refusal to consider climate emergency in forestry planning

Details: Created on Thursday, 06 February 2020 13:24

Ministry-approved plan cites long-cancelled carbon management measures

Photo: Logged forest in the Temagami Forest Management Unit, Earthroots

Ottawa, February 6, 2020 — Ecojustice lawyers, on behalf of Earthroots and Friends of Temagami, have filed a lawsuit against the Ford government for refusing to take into account climate-related considerations in its forestry management plan for Temagami.

“Ontario is required to consider climate change before exempting forestry from environmental assessment. When this condition is not met, the environment ministry is legally required to kick-start the individual environmental assessment process. This didn’t happen for Temagami,” said Joshua Ginsberg, lawyer with Ecojustice’s law clinic at the University of Ottawa. “This is a systemic problem across the province where climate-related impacts are left out of the picture for Ontario’s forests despite the legal requirement for it to be included.”

In Ontario, forestry management plans benefit from a class-based exemption from environmental assessment, provided the Ministry of Natural Resources and Forestry (MNRF) addresses a list of mandatory conditions, including efforts toward climate change mitigation and carbon management.

The MNRF falsely claimed to be developing methodologies for carbon management for Temagami’s forestry management plan — efforts that were underway were suspended in June 2018 and cancelled altogether two months before the region’s management plan was approved.

Given that the province’s ten-year plan for Temagami did not include climate-related considerations as required by law, Earthroots and Friends of Temagami say an individual environmental assessment should have been conducted. The ministry denied the groups’ request for an assessment in May 2019.

“The impacts of climate change on our forest is profound and increasing,” said Gord Miller, former Environmental Commissioner of Ontario and current Earthroots Chair. “If MNRF is to meet its obligation for sustainable forestry management, it must incorporate both the ecological and carbon impacts of our warming planet.”

Ontario's forests are under threat!

Details: Created on Monday, 03 February 2020 03:31

The government is proposing to double logging in Ontario and cut down 30 MILLION cubic metres of wood annually. Tell Ford that our forests are more than timber and aren't "open for business"! Comments are due February 5th.

TAKE ACTION NOW

You can read the draft Forest Sector Strategy on the Environmental Registry of Ontario.

It's not too late to give the gift of the wild!

Details: Created on Monday, 23 December 2019 19:55

Looking for the perfect gift for the wolf lover in your life?

Adopt a wolf pup, pair or pack in their name.

When you adopt wolves in honour of a loved one, you can send them one of our beautiful e-Cards to let them know you are protecting wolves in their name!

All donations from symbolic wolf adoptions go directly towards our work protecting wild wolves in Ontario.

Click here to adopt a wolf today!

A special THANK YOU from Earthroots

Details: Created on Tuesday, 03 December 2019 07:38

_{Photo credit: Algonquin wolf, Helen E. Grose}

With your support in 2019 we've been able to:

Expand the Ontario Wolf Survey with the support of more than 30 citizen scientists and collaborating organizations. We collected 150 non-invasive DNA samples to help find threatened Algonquin wolves.
Ensure that Ontario’s Greenbelt, clean drinking water and precious farmlands were protected from threats under Bill 66, Ford's "Open for Business" Act.
Help build the movement for Grassy Narrows First Nation and their fight for mercury justice. 1,000 people joined 60 members of the community at the River Run march to show their solidarity.

None of our important work to protect Ontario's wilderness, wildlife and watersheds would be possible without YOU!

24 groups call for Ontario to take serious action on climate change

Details: Created on Thursday, 07 November 2019 21:08

Climate Changing

_{Photo: Markus Spiske}

November 7th, 2019

Dear Members of Provincial Parliament,

Welcome back to the legislature. In the months you’ve been away, a lot has happened.

An estimated million Canadians marched in the streets this fall to demand stronger action on climate change, sparked by youth fighting for their future. Climate change became a top election issue in the federal election, with almost 70 percent of MPs elected in Ontario supporting a price on carbon and stronger climate action. Thirty elected Ontario councils have now declared climate emergencies, including Toronto, Ottawa, Sudbury, Barrie, and Hamilton. Canadian doctors and health professionals continued to warn that adverse mental and physical health impacts from heat waves, wildfires, air pollution, floods, and vector-borne diseases like Lyme disease will escalate exponentially without ambitious steps to reduce emissions quickly.

While calls for climate action escalate across our province, Ontario’s government has fallen drastically behind. In the last year we’ve seen the destruction of every program that made Ontario a leader on climate change action. And we’ve seen this government go into hibernation on a crisis that threatens the future of our friends and loved ones.

Instead of ramping up action after the IPCC’s groundbreaking report asking all governments to do more, Ontario weakened their 2030 climate change target and spent a year largely failing to implement effective solutions, even those promised in the Made-In-Ontario Environment Plan.

It’s time for you, as elected officials entrusted with the well-being of your communities, to listen to your constituents, your children, your loved ones, and the youth demanding action and answers every Friday. We are asking you to take leadership to ensure a healthy future on a habitable planet. A leader doesn’t walk away from a crisis because it requires hard work. We are asking you to do the work. We are asking you to lead.

Stop Ontario's War on Wolves!

Details: Created on Sunday, 22 September 2019 20:08

Our moose are in trouble. The Ontario government wants wolves and coyotes to pay the price for declining populations even though their own science shows that a war on wolves won't help moose.

Our wildlife needs your voice now! Click here to send your comments to the key decision-makers.

Deadline is this Thursday (September 26th).

The Progressive Conservatives are re-considering a proposal abandoned by the previous government after it was outed as being unscientific and unethical. If passed, the hunting of both wolves and coyotes will be liberalized across northern Ontario.

This proposal includes:

The elimination of a special game seal that hunters currently have to purchase to kill wolves and coyotes.
The elimination of reporting requirements which will make the limit of 2 wolf kills per hunter per year unenforceable.
Unlimited killing of coyotes, including pups, virtually year-round.

Moose are under serious threat from habitat loss and climate change, and require ecosystem based management that prioritizes their needs. These proposed changes aren’t designed to help moose, they are designed to persecute predators.

The government listened to us last time we urged them to abandon a similar proposal. Together we can ensure that our wildlife species receive better protection in our province.

Temagami Changing of the Seasons Gathering 2019

Details: Created on Monday, 05 August 2019 19:58

_{Photo: Tierney Angus, Friends of Temagami}

Over the weekend of September 7th, 2019 Alex Mathias, an Ojibway Elder, will host his annual Changing of the Seasons Ceremony to celebrate the fall equinox on his traditional family territory in the Temagami region of Ontario.

On Saturday there will be a 'Changing of the Seasons' ceremony, a group potluck lunch, visits to Spirit Rock, and guided hikes through the old-growth forest. Attendees have the option of participating in group events after the ceremony, exploring the area on their own, or simply enjoying some quiet time on the lake. There is no structured agenda for the weekend and Sunday is an open day.

All are welcome! If you have never been to Temagami and have always wanted to go, this is a great opportunity to experience the wilderness in a group setting.

Endangered species to make way for sprawl development

Details: Created on Thursday, 06 June 2019 17:58

"More Homes, More Choice Act" guts protections for Ontario's most vulnerable plants and animals

TORONTO, June 6, 2019 /CNW/ - Today the Government of Ontario passed the More Homes, More Choice Act, a law that opens significant wildlife habitat to sprawl development through amendments to the Endangered Species Act, 2007 (ESA). The amendments give new powers to the Minister to delay, limit and remove protections for at-risk species. Further, it creates numerous, overlapping pathways for developers and industrialists to dodge critical requirements.

"The Endangered Species Act has been torn to shreds," says Kelsey Scarfone, program manager with Environmental Defence. "Those with a vested, short-term economic interest in sprawl development now have free rein to bulldoze, dig up and pave over the habitats of our most vulnerable plants and animals."

"The forestry industry, which is contributing to, if not driving, the decline of boreal caribou in Ontario, successfully lobbied in the past for exemptions to the ESA meaning they didn't have to comply with the prohibitions," says Rachel Plotkin, Boreal Project Manager with the David Suzuki Foundation. "Now there is no need for an exemption—the ESA has been weakened to the extent that status quo logging operations can continue under its watch."

In the face of growing opposition to the proposed law, the provincial government chose to ram the Bill through the Legislature, curtailing debate and ignoring the serious concerns of environmental organizations, scientists, Indigenous voices, municipalities and tens of thousands of citizens.

"These changes do not reflect the values or long-term interests of the people of Ontario. The haste with which the government proceeded ensured that Ontarians would have no say in the outcome," says Anne Bell, director of conservation and education at Ontario Nature. "Calls to engage in genuine public consultation over the coming summer were swept aside." The amendments also reduce future opportunities for public input on ESA matters under the Environmental Bill of Rights.

The ESA gutting follows a ground-breaking United Nations report, released in May, that documents the rapid decline of ecosystems and accelerating rates of species extinction. According to the report, a million species are now threatened with extinction.

"These changes to the ESA take us in the wrong direction," says Gord Miller Chair of Earthroots and former Environmental Commissioner of Ontario. "The alarming patterns of biodiversity loss, outlined in the United Nations report, hold true everywhere, including Ontario, and threaten the very foundations of our well-being and our economies."

Job Opportunity - Campaign Director

Details: Created on Thursday, 28 February 2019 00:38

_{Photo credits: Algonquin wolf by Wesley Liikane, Temagami Red Squirrel Road blockade (Earthroots), ancient white pine by Hap Wilson}

Earthroots is hiring!

The Campaign Director is responsible for delivering high impact campaigns that will educate and mobilize the public.

Reporting to the Executive Director, the Campaign Director will lead the development and implementation of Earthroots’ campaigns in collaboration with our small team, mainly working out of our Toronto office.

Earthroots Open Source Content Management

Nav view search

Navigation

Search

Welcome to Earthroots